Internet Gaming Disorder and Sleep Quality among Jordanian University Students: A Cross-sectional Study

1. INTRODUCTION

Video gaming is an emerging form of entertainment that is easily accessible and available to almost everyone nowadays. According to The American Psychiatric Association (APA), around 160 million American adults play internet-based games, and 97% of American children and adolescents play video games for at least 1 hour [1]. This popularity and extensive usage of video games raise concerns about their negative and positive effects on society and individuals’ physical and mental health. Interestingly, specific terms and disorders have been linked to video games, such as Internet Gaming Disorder, excessive video gaming, and even video game addiction, which is similar to other behavioral addictions, such as substance abuse [2].

This research paper revolves around Internet Gaming Disorder (IGD), which is defined as “Persistent and recurrent use of the internet to engage in games, often with other players, leading to clinically significant impairment or distress.” Despite the debate and criticism among researchers on whether to include it or not [3, 4], IGD was first introduced in 2013 in the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, which suggested carrying out further investigation among different populations [5]. In 2018, Gaming Disorder (GD) officially became a type of addiction as the World Health Organization released the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) [6].

Previous researchers have reported significant variations in the prevalence rates of IGD across many countries. According to a meta-analysis of 27 studies from 2007 to 2016, the overall prevalence of IGD ranges between 0.7% and 15.6% [7]. Another meta-analysis of 16 studies on the adolescent population showed a prevalence of 4.6% [8]. However, IGD prevalence is highly variable among different populations, countries, and assessment tools. It reached 38.2% in a sample of 555 Brazilian secondary school students and undergraduates [9]. Another study involving 6000 young adults aged 18-25 years in the United States revealed a prevalence of 24.33% [10]. A different representative study in seven European countries involving 12,938 adolescents aged 14-17 years showed that only 1.6% of the participants have IGD [11]. In Germany, the prevalence of IGD is 1.16% among 11.003 participants aged 13-18 years [12], while in Lebanon, it was 9.2% among 524 participants aged 15–19 years [13].

Video games have been linked to positive social, motivational, cognitive, and emotional effects [1], and improving visual short-term memory [14]. Adolescents with IGD also displayed increased brain activity in the parietal lobe and left orbitofrontal cortex [15]. Despite these benefits, many negative impacts have been associated with IGD including insomnia, depression, anxiety, psychoticism, lower family and extra-family relationships, decreased cognitive control, and increased prefrontal cortex inhibition. Additionally, changes in gray matter volume in different areas of the brain may impair craving and self-control, while alterations in brain networks can contribute to the development and maintenance of IGD and impulse control issues [16-23]. The severity of IGD has also been associated with greater psychological distress and poorer sleep quality [24]. Students with IGD had a higher incidence of suicidal thoughts and self-harm and a higher likelihood of smoking [25-27]. Interestingly, one study showed that adolescents with IGD can affect their sibling’s psychological health and sleep [28].

Many countries have reported a high prevalence of sleep disturbances in our youth, raising international concerns about adolescent sleep health [29]. Poor sleep quality has significant adverse effects on well-being and overall quality of life, including one’s ability to function throughout the day, health problems, perception of pain, the general perception of one’s health and vitality, social functioning, and mental health [30]. Several studies have linked IGD with sleep problems. One study showed that 28.2% of internet gamers had sleep problems in Singapore [31]. A meta-analysis of 33 studies among 26 countries and more than 50,000 participants found that problematic gaming is significantly associated with shorter sleep duration, poorer sleep quality, daytime sleepiness, and sleep problems [32].

The objective of this study is to investigate the prevalence of internet gaming disorder (IGD) and its association with sleep quality and academic performance among Jordanian university students aged 18-26. Our literature review reveals a lack of research on this topic in Jordan concerning this specific population and culture. Therefore, our study aims to contribute to the existing literature and to raise awareness about the impact of IGD on two main aspects of university students' lives: their sleep quality and academic performance.

2. METHODS

3. RESULTS

A total of 2437 participants completed the questionnaire. After excluding participants under the age of 18 or above 26, incomplete questionnaires, and participants previously diagnosed with psychiatric or neurological disorders, 2005 participants (82.2%) were included in the study. The study sample had a higher ratio of females (52.5%, n=1053) to males. Most participants (62.7%, n=1258) were between 18-20 years old, and 68.5% (n=1373) were from the middle region of Jordan. The participants attended 30 different universities across Jordan, with the most common being The University of Jordan (28.9%, n=580) and Jordan University of Science and Technology (13.4%, n=269). About one-third of the study population were students of scientific majors (35.6%, n=713), followed by students of health majors and students of humanities majors (35.5%, n=711 and 29%, n=581, respectively). The main reasons for internet use were social media (55.9%, n=1120) and studying (28.3%, n=568). The average gaming and social media hours per day were 1.8 and 5.2 hours, respectively. Detailed demographic information is summarized in Table 1.

The participants' average IGD score was 2.48 out of 9, with 15.2% (n=305) of the participants having IGD and 25.2% (n=506) of them being risky players. Among The University of Jordan students, the prevalence of IGD and risky gamers were 15% (n=87) and 24.5% (n=142), respectively. IGD and being a risky gamer were more prevalent among males compared to females (p= <0.001), and they were more prevalent among students of scientific majors and humanities majors compared to health majors (p=0.018). Age, region, GPA, family income, living in the countryside, and hours spent on social media were not significantly associated with either IGD status. Detailed information regarding IGD status and its association with demographic factors is shown in Table 2 and Fig. (1).

The average PSQI score for our sample is 6.91 out of 24, with 35.4% (n=710) of participants reporting good sleep quality and 64.6% (n=1295) of them reporting poor sleep quality. Among The University of Jordan students, 61.4% (n=356) had poor sleep quality, and 38.6% (n=224) had good sleep quality. A closer examination of sleep components revealed a significant correlation between IGD status and subjective sleep quality, sleep disturbance, use of sleep medication, and daytime dysfunction (p<0.05). More details are shown in Table 3. Poor sleep quality was significantly more common in females, lower family income groups, participants with IGD, and risky gamers (p<0.05). Fig. (2) illustrates PSQI scores distributed by gender and IGD status. Hours spent on social media per day were also significantly associated with sleep quality (p<0.05). Binary logistic regression analysis indicated that being a risky gamer and having IGD (OR=1.397, 1.882 respectively), spending more hours on social media (OR=1.38), and having a lower family income (OR=1.592) were significant predictors of poor sleep quality when adjusted for other variables. Further details are shown in Table 4.

4. DISCUSSION

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to investigate IGD prevalence and its association with gender, academic achievements, and sleep quality among Jordanian university students. We found that 15.2% of Jordanian university students have IGD, a high prevalence compared to 9.2% in Lebanon [13], 6.1% among 423 gamers in 3 Arab countries including Jordan [17], 7.1% in Pakistan [39], 5.3% in the US [25], 1.6% among 7 European countries [11], and 4.6% in a Meta-analysis across 3 decades on adolescents aged 10-19 years [8]. A recent meta-analysis conducted on 19 studies in Asia and 3 in Europe found that the pooled prevalence among all ages was 6.7% [40]. Restricting the analysis to students at the University of Jordan, the largest university in the country, showed a similar pattern (15% with IGD and 24.5% being risky gamers). A recent study in a single university in Egypt which shares a similar socio-cultural environment with Jordan found that 6% of the students aged 18-25 years old had IGD [41], this high prevalence in our study may be due to the recruitment of a young age group (18-26), who are more likely to play video games than the general population, as prior studies found that the prevalence of video game addiction decreased with age and being younger is associated with IGD [42, 43]. Additionally, our study was conducted after the COVID-19 pandemic and quarantine measures, unlike many of the studies mentioned, which were conducted before the pandemic. A large study in Japan found that IGD prevalence has increased during the COVID-19 pandemic by 1.6 times compared to before the pandemic [44]. On the other hand, Brazil had a higher IGD prevalence of 38.2% [9] and 19.9% in England [45]. This variability in prevalence can be attributed to different assessment tools and thresholds, as well as different age groups and populations. Although two studies in Pakistan and Slovenia used the same tool we used in our study (IGDS9-SF) in a nearly similar age group (16-28 and 12-16 years old respectively), their IGD prevalence was 1.5% and 2.5%, respectively [46, 47].

In our study, the prevalence of being a risky gamer (25.2%) is higher than the IGD prevalence (15.2%). This is consistent with a study in Pakistan, which showed that 25.2% of the sample were risky gamers and 7.1% had IGD [39]. Similarly, a study in the US showed the same pattern, with 9.2% being risky gamers and 5.3% having IGD [25]. Other studies in Egypt and Lebanon also showed higher percentages of risky gamers compared to those with IGD (50% vs. 13.6% in Egypt and 35.7% vs. 9.2% in Lebanon) [13, 48]. These results can be explained by needing a lower threshold and lower score to be a risky gamer before having IGD.

Despite the higher number of females who participated in our study (52.5%), we found that IGD is significantly associated with the male gender, with19% of males having IGD compared to 11.8% of females. In contrast, a study at the University of Mansoura in Egypt did not find any significant gender difference in IGD prevalence [41]. Nevertheless, our result aligns with many studies showing higher prevalence in males compared to females. For example, the prevalence of IGD in European adolescent males was 3.1%, and in females was 0.3% [11]. Similar results were demonstrated in a Nationwide German study with a large sample of 44,610 participants [49]. A Canadian study showed that Males were also significantly more likely to have IGD than females (15.1% vs. 3.1%, respectively) [50]. Additionally, studies in Slovenia, Germany and Brazil demonstrated that being male is a risk factor for IGD [9, 51, 52]. Another study in Norway showed that males report more problems with gaming than females [43]. Siste et al. [53] from Indonesia found that males were 4 times more likely to have internet gaming disorder than females. This result can be explained by the male preference for certain game genres, which themselves are more time-consuming and demanding [52]. Moreover, functional magnetic resonance imaging studies showcased a higher activity in the mesocorticolimbic pathway in males compared to females when playing video games [54]. Males were also more sensitive to gaming-related rewards and higher cravings than females [55]. In addition, males spent more time playing video games. A national study conducted in the US found that the average playtime for males was 16.4 hours per week, compared to 9.2 hours per week for females [56]. Furthermore, our findings showed that increased gaming hours were associated with IGD. These findings parallel the results of previous studies looking into the link between gaming time and IGD risk [57]. Additionally, socio-cultural factors, such as outdoor gaming centers being mostly frequented by males in our country, may contribute to the higher IGD prevalence among males.

GPA was not associated with IGD in our study, in contrast to 2 large studies in Germany [10, 47] and one across 7 European countries [11], which found that students with IGD had lower grades in school and diminished academic performance. This discrepancy can be explained by the fact that 24.3% of the sample were in their first semester at university, so they did not have GPAs yet, which might have affected our results. Age was also not associated with having IGD, similar to a study among European adolescents aged between (14-17) years [11]. This could be due to the narrow age group range (18-26) used in our study, resulting in participants with a similar lifestyle. Moreover, 2 studies in Norway assessed IGD in wide age groups ((15-40) years and (16-74) years respectively) and found that young age is significantly associated with IGD [42, 43].

64.6% of Jordanian university students reported poor sleep quality, which is similar to 60% of Al-Azhar university students [48] and 65.4% of Ethiopian adults [58]. This high prevalence should raise a national concern as sleep disorders play a central role in the development of Dysregulation of mood, energy, and social rhythms syndrome (DYMERS); a newly emerged concept that carries a substantial influence on health-related quality of life and can be a consequence for many disorders such as panic disorder [59, 60].

In comparison to normal gamers, our results showed that participants with IGD and risky gamers had lower subjective sleep quality, sleep disturbance, daytime dysfunction, and use of sleep medication. Previous studies have established a link between pathological gaming and poor sleep quality. IGD has many effects on different components of sleep, and it was linked to sleeping duration [13], sleep disorders and insomnia [61], and daytime tiredness [62]. Furthermore, IGD was associated with poorer sleep quality, consistent with research conducted in France [63], Pakistan [39], and the US [25]. These results can be explained by the fact that students with IGD were more likely to delay their bedtimes and shorten their total time spent sleeping or even wake up during the night to continue gaming [13, 64]. Playing online games triggers the release of norepinephrine in the cortex and dopamine in the midbrain. These neurotransmitters are part of the reticular activating system (RAS) and are responsible for keeping gamers awake [65]. Additionally, light exposure during gaming can suppress melatonin production, a hormone produced by the pineal gland at night and in darkness [66]. Furthermore, for many gamers, staying up late to play can be a socially rewarding experience [67]. All these negative effects of IGD on sleep quality highlight the need for treatment. Two recent systematic reviews found that non-pharmacotherapy modalities such as behavioral therapy (CBT)/multi-level counseling (MLC) and pharmacotherapy treatments such as bupropion, methylphenidate, and a range of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors are all effective in treating IGD [68, 69].

There are a few limitations associated with this study that should be addressed. This study, as with any cross-sectional study, has an inherent bias as it measures both the exposure and the outcome simultaneously, making it difficult to determine causality. Accordingly, this study cannot support causal links due to the lack of a time dimension. The survey was conducted via an online questionnaire, and convenience and snowball sampling were used to collect data, both of which could have resulted in sampling bias. Since questionnaires were distributed to acquaintances who may share common characteristics and participants were chosen based on availability, there is a risk of self-selection bias. Additionally, participants may not have accurate time perception. Our data collection tool is slightly bulky, including more than 40 questions, and some participants may answer some questions carelessly. Further research should explore the long-term effects of IGD on academic performance and mental health among university students. Longitudinal studies could provide deeper insights into the causative factors and effectiveness of various intervention strategies in different ethnic and age groups (Supplementary material-IDG).

CONCLUSION

Internet Gaming Disorder (IGD) is common among Jordanian university students and is significantly associated with poor sleep quality. Our findings emphasize the need for urgent intervention and targeted strategies to mitigate the effects of IGD on this vulnerable population. Policymakers, educators, and healthcare providers must raise awareness about IGD and its impact on sleep quality. Efforts are necessary to identify individuals at risk and to implement early interventions to protect future generations from this emerging global issue and its consequences, which impose a high burden on society.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION

It is hereby acknowledged that all authors have accepted responsibility for the manuscript's content and consented to its submission. They have meticulously reviewed all results and unanimously approved the final version of the manuscript.

REFERENCES